State of Florida

pscSEAL

 

Public Service Commission

Capital Circle Office Center ● 2540 Shumard Oak Boulevard
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0850

-M-E-M-O-R-A-N-D-U-M-

 

DATE:

November 17, 2026

TO:

Office of Commission Clerk (Teitzman)

FROM:

Office of the General Counsel (Sapoznikoff) SMC

Division of Economics (Hampson) EJD

RE:

Docket No. 20260158-EU – Petition to initiate rulemaking under 120.54(7), F.S., to designate the measurement and reporting methodology for large load customers under 366.043, F.S., by Green Recursive Utility Service LLC.

AGENDA:

12/01/26 – Regular Agenda – Interested Persons May Participate

COMMISSIONERS ASSIGNED:

All Commissioners

PREHEARING OFFICER:

Ortega

CRITICAL DATES:

12/01/26 (The Commission must grant or deny the Petition by this date.)

RULE STATUS

May Not Be Deferred

SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS:

None

 

 Case Background

On October 30, 2026, Green Recursive Utility Service, LLC (Green Recursive or Petitioner) filed a Petition for Rulemaking (Petition). The Petition requests that the Commission initiate rulemaking pursuant to Section 120.54(7), Florida Statutes (F.S.), to adopt a new rule within Chapter 25-6 of the Florida Administrative Code (F.A.C), which chapter pertains to electric utilities. The Petitioner requests that this new rule incorporate by reference GRUS-STD-60084 v2.0-U (Uniform Edition), DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23246001 (proposed standard), “as the measurement and reporting methodology for large load service under § 364.043, Florida Statutes.” The Petitioner states that it is the creator of the proposed standard.

Pursuant to Section 120.54(7)(a), F.S., any person regulated by an agency or having a substantial interest in an agency rule may petition an agency to adopt, amend, or repeal a rule. The Petitioner alleges it has a substantial interest in an agency rule, and the Petition specifies the proposed rule and action requested.[1]

This recommendation addresses whether the Commission should initiate rulemaking or deny the Petition. This recommendation does not address the merits of the Petitioner’s suggested rule language or whether the Petitioner’s suggested rule satisfies the requirements of Section 120.52 and 120.54, F.S. The Commission has jurisdiction pursuant to Section 120.54, 350.127(2), and 366.05(1), F.S.

 

 


Discussion of Issues

Issue 1: 

 Should the Commission grant Green Recursive’s Petition to Initiate Rulemaking?

Recommendation: 

 No. The Commission should deny the Petition. (Sapoznikoff, Hampson)

Staff Analysis: 

 

The Petition

The Petitioner states it is a Texas limited liability company that is the author and publisher of GRUS-STD-60084, which it indicates is “a measurement standard for data centers and large load water and energy consumption.” The Petitioner requests that the Commission adopt a new rule under Chapter 25-6, F.A.C. to incorporate by reference GRUS-STD-60084 v2.0-U (Uniform Edition), DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23246001 “as the measurement and reporting methodology for large load service under § 364.043, Florida Statutes.”

 

In its Petition, Green Recursive alleges the following to demonstrate that it has a substantial interest in whether the Commission initiates rulemaking:

 

1. Petitioner is the author of the subject matter of the proposed rule. The rule proposed in Annex A designates a single measurement and reporting methodology for large load service under § 366.043: GRUS-STD-60084 v2.0-U (Uniform Edition), DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23246001. Petitioner wrote that standard, publishes it, maintains it, and is the person answerable for its content. A Commission decision to designate the standard makes Petitioner's own work product the operative measurement method for Florida large load service; a decision to refuse designation, or to designate a different or no method, determines with equal directness the standing of that same work product. No other person stands in that relation to the proposed rule.

 

2. Petitioner is a practitioner under the proposed rule, not a commentator on it. Petitioner performs facility consumption audits in the standard's audit form (GRUS-AUD), including the granular consumption audit of the Circle T facility in Texas (GRUS-AUD-CTDC-R1, September 2026), which was submitted to the City of Keller and the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality and sworn into the record of that proceeding, with third parties standing on it. If the Commission designates the methodology, Petitioner's audit practice is the practice the designation describes; the rule regulates the form of work Petitioner itself performs.

 

3. The interest is direct, particular, and distinct from the general public's. Petitioner does not plead the interest of a Florida ratepayer, and does not rest on the public's interest in sound ratemaking, which it shares with everyone. It pleads the interest of the standard's author and of an audit practitioner in the designation decision itself — an interest that exists whether or not Petitioner ever takes electric service in Florida, and that is affected by the Commission's grant or denial of this petition in a way no member of the general public's interest is.

 

4. No proprietary stake is asserted. The standard is dedicated to the public domain under CC0. Designation creates no royalty, license fee, or proprietary dependency running to Petitioner or to any party; Petitioner's interest is the authorial and professional interest stated above, stated openly so the Commission can weigh it for exactly what it is.

 

The Petitioner alleges rulemaking is necessary because although “Florida has ordered the cost determination; it has not designated a method for making it.” The Petitioner asserts:

 

The Legislature specified the threshold measurement and the conclusion the numbers must support, and left the production of every other number to convention. Three utilities have now produced three tariffs on three conventions, and the Commission's staff, reviewing them, has recommended three different procedural outcomes. There is nothing in any of the three records that would let the Commission — or a ratepayer, or this Petitioner — restate Duke's figures, Tampa Electric's figures, and FPL's figures in a common form and test them against the same test.

 

In addition, the Petitioner alleges in its Petition that the large load dockets of Duke Energy Florida,[2] Tampa Electric Company,[3] and Florida Power & Light Company[4] demonstrate “the absence of a designated method.” The Petition alleges “Timing is the substance.” The Petition states:

 

The first § 366.043 tariffs are being acted on now, and the compliance conventions adopted in these first dockets — by approval, by suspension orders, or by refiled tariffs — are the conventions later proceedings must displace if a common method is adopted afterward. A method placed before the Commission while the first generation of tariffs is still open can be built into the template those

tariffs set; the same method offered after the template hardens arrives as a request to reopen finished work.

Finally, the Petitioner states that the proposed standard it created should be used for three reasons:

First, it classifies each facility by measured characteristics — a consumption classification (water-use categories W-1 through W-3 crossed with consumption classes C-1 through C-5) computed from the facility's filed load and site conditions, not from the facility's own description of itself. Second, it accounts granularly — load, energy, and water (withdrawal, consumption, and evaporation, by source and by use) — at the granularity a full-cost determination requires if it is to be checked rather than credited. Third, it carries its own verification protocol in audit form (GRUS-AUD), under which a reported figure is checked against metered records, so a compliance showing is a verifiable document rather than an attestation.

 

The Requested Rule Language

The Petition requests that the Commission adopt the following rule language:

 

ANNEX A — PROPOSED RULE TEXT

New rule, Chapter 25-6, Florida Administrative Code (numbering to be assigned by the Commission): Measurement and reporting methodology for large load service.

1. Purpose and applicability. This rule designates the measurement and reporting methodology for service to a large load customer, as defined in § 366.043(2)(d), Florida Statutes, under the tariffs required by § 366.043, Florida Statutes. It applies to each public utility providing or offering electric service to a large load customer.

2. Definitions. Large load customer — as defined in § 366.043(2)(d), Florida Statutes. Standard — GRUS-STD-60084 v2.0-U (Uniform Edition), published by Green Recursive Utility Service LLC, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23246001, dedicated to the public domain under CC0 1.0, incorporated by reference.

3. Measurement method. The anticipated and actual peak load, energy consumption, and associated resource consumption (including water consumed for cooling) figures on which a public utility's tariff, cost-of-service showing, compliance filing, or report for large load service rests shall be measured and stated in accordance with the Standard, including: (a) metered measurement of load and consumption at or near the point of delivery, with peak load stated consistently with § 366.043(2)(d), Florida Statutes; (b) a statement accompanying each filing or report of the metered quantities and the measurement method from which each reported figure is derived; and (c) the consumption classification of the facility served, computed under the Standard.

4. Verification. A filing or report stating figures measured under this rule is subject to verification in the audit form of the Standard (GRUS-AUD), under which reported quantities are checked against metered records.

5. Availability. The Standard is available to the Commission, to public utilities, and to the public at no cost at DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23246001. Incorporation by reference creates no license fee or royalty obligation.

6. No other effect. This rule designates a measurement and reporting methodology only. It prescribes no rate, charge, contract term, or service condition, and does not modify any requirement of § 366.043, Florida Statutes, or of any tariff.

 

The thrust of the suggested rule language is to incorporate by reference GRUS-STD-60084 v2.0-U (Uniform Edition), a “standard” created by the Petitioner. However, that standard was not provided as part of the filing by the Petitioner.[5]

 

Analysis

Staff recommends that the Commission deny the Petition. Staff believes that no new rule is required or necessary at this time to implement Section 366.043, F.S.

 

In enacting Section 366.043, F.S., the Florida Legislature did not require the Commission adopt rules to implement the new statute. Moreover, Section 366.043, F.S., is facially clear, and staff does not believe an additional rule is needed at this time to obtain information not required by the statute or an existing rule.[6]

 

Section 366.043, F.S., requires certain utilities to file a tariff that complies with specified “minimum tariff and service requirements.” Those “minimum tariff and service requirements” are the types of things that the Commission already considers in setting tariffs and for which the Commission already has rules, to the extent rules are necessary. These include cost of service, involvement of foreign entities, contributions in aid of construction, demand charges, incremental generation charges, financial guarantees, minimum load factors, “take-or-pay provisions,” and minimum period of service contract requirements.

 

The fact that the Commission is applying its existing rules on a case-by-case basis according to the unique nature of each utility is not a fault as alleged by the Petitioner. Rather, staff believes it demonstrates that additional rules are not needed at this time. As the Commission reviews the large load tariffs submitted by the required utilities and specifically considers how these tariffs are implemented, the Commission can determine if any additional rules are required and what type of rules most appropriately address the nature of large loads in Florida.

 

In addition, as mentioned above, the Petitioner did not attach to the Petition nor otherwise provide the proposed standard it seeks the Commission to incorporate by reference. While the Petition alleges the standard “is available to the Commission, to public utilities, and to the public at no cost,” the Commission should not bear the responsibility to search for and obtain that foundational information.

 

The Petitioner’s failure to provide the proposed standard it seeks the Commission to incorporate by reference in the rule deprives the Commission of the ability to assess the necessity and appropriateness of the proposed standard. According to the Petition, this proposed standard has been unsuccessfully marketed to Texas, Ohio, Arizona, New Jersey, Kansas, and Virginia. See “E. Record Elsewhere (one line)” in the Petition. Staff believes that the fact that this same standard apparently has been presented as appropriate to so many diverse jurisdictions, each having its own, differing enabling legislation, raises concern. Moreover, from staff’s investigation, it does not appear that the proposed standard is officially recognized or adopted by any national utility metering standard-setting organization (such as ANSI, IEEE, or the American Water Works Association).

 

As a side note, staff questions whether the Petitioner actually has a substantial interest in the rule as required by Section 120.54(7)(a), F.S., and as alleged in the Petition. The Petitioner is not a utility regulated by the Commission. The Petitioner is not a customer of any utility regulated by the Commission. The Petitioner merely has a product it wants the Commission to use.

 

While the proposed standard is purportedly publicly available and provides “no royalty, license fee, or proprietary dependency running to Petitioner,” incorporation of this proposed standard into a Commission rule could establish a market for the Petitioner’s own downstream third-party auditing services and/or hardware optimization licenses. The Petition states:

 

The Petitioner is a practitioner under the proposed rule, not a commentator on it. Petitioner performs facility consumption audits in the standard's audit form (GRUS-AUD), . . . . If the Commission designates the methodology, Petitioner's audit practice is the practice the designation describes; the rule regulates the form of work Petitioner itself performs.

 

A substantial interest “is one based on a legal entitlement, and not on a mere unilateral expectation.” Herold v. Univ. of S. Fla., 806 So. 2d 638, 640 (Fla. 2d DCA 2002) A claim based on economic interests is not sufficient. See Gadsden Jai Alai, Inc. v. State, 26 So. 3d 68, 69 (Fla. 1st DCA 2010)(regarding standing of a third party to intervene in or initiate an administrative proceeding). Accordingly, it is staff’s opinion that the Petitioner does not have a substantial interest in the requested rulemaking and, even if it did, for the reasons expressed above, staff believes rulemaking is not required or necessary.

 

Conclusion

For the reasons stated above, the Commission should deny the Petition to Initiate Rulemaking.


 

Issue 2: 

 Should this docket be closed?

Recommendation: 

 Yes, if the Commission approves staff’s recommendation in Issue 1, this docket should be closed. (Sapoznikoff)

Staff Analysis: 

 If the Commission approves staff’s recommendation in Issue 1, this docket should be closed.

 



[1] As discussed further in the Recommendation, based on the facts alleged in the Petition, the Petitioner may not have demonstrated it has a substantial interest in whether the Commission adopts a rule implementing Section 366.043, F.S.

[2] Docket No. 20260064-EI.

[3] Docket No. 20260146-EI.

[4] Docket No. 20260149-EI.

[5] Although the suggested rule language and the Petition indicate that the standard is publicly available, cursory searches of the internet for “GRUS-STD-60084” and DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23246001” most frequently return links to Facebook postings. There is some indication that the standard is a 72-page document. However, the proposed standard (“Annex A”) attached to the Petitioner’s filing in Texas, which the Petitioner purports to be the same standard to be incorporated here, is only 30 pages. Additionally, the attachment to the Texas filing is illegible. Finally, the document identified as “GRUS-STD-60084” (version 2) on the Petitioner’s own website appears to be an October 6, 2026, companion document to the October 1, 2026, Texas filing.

[6] A rule is “an agency statement of general applicability that implements, interprets, or prescribes law or policy or describes the procedure or practice requirements of an agency and includes any form which imposes any requirement or solicits any information not specifically required by statute or by an existing rule.” Section 120.52(16), F.S.