State of Florida

pscSEAL

 

Public Service Commission

Capital Circle Office Center ● 2540 Shumard Oak Boulevard
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0850

-M-E-M-O-R-A-N-D-U-M-

 

DATE:

November 17, 2026

TO:

Office of Commission Clerk (Teitzman)

FROM:

Division of Economics (Prewett, Barrett, Clark, McNulty)

Office of the General Counsel (Crawford, Rauch)

RE:

Docket No. 20260121-EU – Joint petition for approval of amended and restated territorial agreement in Gadsden County, by Talquin Electric Cooperative and Town of Havana.

AGENDA:

12/1/26 – Regular Agenda – Proposed Agency Action - Interested Persons May Participate

COMMISSIONERS ASSIGNED:

All Commissioners

PREHEARING OFFICER:

Clark

CRITICAL DATES:

None

SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS:

None

 

 Case Background

On August 20, 2026, Talquin Electric Cooperative (Talquin) and the Town of Havana (Havana) (collectively the joint petitioners or Utilities), filed a petition seeking Commission approval of a territorial agreement in Gadsden County (2026 Territorial Agreement) with a 30-year term. The 2026 Territorial Agreement provides details on the boundary line changes and includes maps depicting the new territorial boundaries and written descriptions that are attached hereto as Attachment A. 

Since 2006, Talquin and Havana have been parties to an agreement in Gadsden County, which expired in 2026 (2006 Agreement).[1] Since the expiration of that agreement, the joint petitioners have been working on the 2026 Territorial Agreement, which is intended to replace the expired agreement in the above-referenced county. Although the 2006 Agreement expired, the Utilities have continued to meet their obligations under that agreement while negotiations for the 2026 Territorial Agreement were underway.

As discussed in this recommendation, the negotiated 2026 Territorial Agreement, in part, is intended to facilitate the orderly transfer of two facilities from Talquin to Havana, to align the territorial boundary with the current parcel boundaries, and to provide for historical changes in service.[2] Other boundary line changes are proposed to allow extra-territorial customers to remain with the electric utility to which they are currently connected.[3]

The proposed 2026 Territorial Agreement provides in Section 2.4 that Talquin may continue to serve a current member located in Havana, until one of the following occurs: (1) the member requests to become a customer of Havana, (2) the service location is sold, assigned, or otherwise transferred, or (3) a new customer applies for service at that location. Section 2.4 is a pivotal consideration in staff’s evaluation of the 2026 Territorial Agreement and primary and alternate recommendations are presented for the Commission to consider. 

On October 14, 2026, the designated representative of the Talquin customer residing in Havana, contacted the Commission with questions about this matter. The email and staff’s written reply to the representative is filed as Correspondence in this docket. On November 3, 2026, the Talquin customer mailed a letter formally objecting to the account’s electric service being transferred to Havana; the letter is filed as Correspondence in the docket.

This recommendation presents two staff perspectives on one provision of the proposed 2026 Territorial Agreement. Staff agrees on the remaining provisions, but differs on Section 2.4, which would allow Talquin to continue serving one longstanding residential customer within Havana’s proposed service territory, thereby creating an extra-territorial customer, until a specified event triggers transfer. The primary recommendation supports this accommodation under the customer’s particular circumstances, with a reporting requirement. The alternative recommends removing the exception because of concerns about continued uneconomic duplication over an unspecified period. The staff analysis explains the basis for each recommendation.

During the review process, staff issued two data requests to the joint petitioners, for which responses were received September 15 and October 15, 2026. The Commission has jurisdiction over this matter pursuant to Section 366.04, Florida Statues (F.S.).


Discussion of Issues

Issue 1: 

 Should the Commission approve the 2026 Territorial Agreement between Talquin and Havana in Gadsden County, dated August 20, 2026?

Primary Recommendation: 

 Yes, subject to the condition detailed below, the Commission should approve the 2026 Territorial Agreement between Talquin and Havana in Gadsden County, as consistent with the Standards for Approval set forth in Rule 25-6.0440(2), F.A.C. The 2026 Territorial Agreement, if approved, amends the respective boundary lines between the Utilities, thereby eliminating most extra-territorial connections. The agreement would also facilitate the joint petitioners’ efforts to avoid uneconomic duplication of service facilities, wasteful expenditures, and hazardous conditions, as well as the transfer of two facilities from Talquin to Havana. Additionally, the territorial boundary changes will provide the joint petitioners with greater certainty to plan for growth and avoid future disputes. Talquin should be required to notify the Commission in writing within 30 days of the date it permanently discontinues electric service to the customer in Havana. (Prewett, Barrett)

Alternative Recommendation: All aspects of the proposed 2026 Territorial Agreement between Talquin and Havana in Gadsden County are appropriate except for Section 2.4, which would allow Talquin to provide electric service for an unspecified amount of time to an address located in Havana’s service area until one of three conditions are met. This exception to compliance with the proposed boundary lines contemplated in Section 2.4 may result in continued uneconomic duplication in the immediate geographic area for an unspecified period, such that the Agreement represents a detriment to the public interest. After providing required transfer notification and comparative utility rate information to the customer in Havana, the joint petitioners should be required to submit a revision to the proposed 2026 Territorial Agreement that is exclusive of the provisions contained in Section 2.4. (Clark, McNulty)

Staff Analysis: 

 Pursuant to Section 366.04(2)(d), F.S., and Rule 25-6.0440(2), (F.A.C.), the Commission has jurisdiction to approve territorial agreements between and among rural electric cooperatives, municipal electric utilities, and investor-owned electric utilities. Unless the Commission determines that the Agreement will cause a detriment to the public interest, it should be approved.[4]

Rule 25-6.0440(2), F.A.C., addresses the standards the Commission should consider for approving territorial agreements for electric utilities. The rule states:

 

(2) Standards for Approval. In approving territorial agreements, the Commission may consider:

(a) The reasonableness of the purchase price of any facilities being transferred;

(b) The reasonable likelihood that the agreement, in and of itself, will not cause a decrease in the reliability of electrical service to the existing or future ratepayers of any utility party to the agreement;

(c) The reasonable likelihood that the agreement will eliminate existing or potential uneconomic duplication of facilities; and

(d) Any other factor the Commission finds relevant in reaching a determination that the territorial agreement is in the public interest.

 

Proposed 2026 Territorial Agreement

Talquin and Havana executed the 2026 Territorial Agreement addressing common boundaries over the Gadsden County area on August 20, 2026, to replace and supersede the existing territorial agreement from 2006. The joint petitioners assert that the 2026 Territorial Agreement will primarily align the territorial boundaries with the current parcel boundaries and also provide for historical changes in service. [5]

The 2026 Territorial Agreement includes nine maps depicting the new territorial boundaries, written descriptions of the territorial areas, and comprehensive terms and conditions the joint petitioners negotiated. Among other things, the terms address the provision of new and temporary service, the correction of inadvertent service errors, and the procedures for the transfer of facilities. The 2026 Territorial Agreement also includes the joint petitioners’ negotiated terms regarding the method of compensation for transferred facilities. The joint petitioners’ filing does not include a sample copy of notification letters provided to customers, as there are no customers subject to transfer.

There are two sections of Talquin electric utility lines and associated facilities that are proposed to be transferred from Talquin to Havana. These facilities are identified in Exhibit B-1 and B-2 of the proposed Agreement.[6] Section 3.3 of the proposed Agreement outlines the compensation for the transferring facilities. Within six months of the Commission’s approval of the proposed Agreement, the two sections of Talquin facilities located within Havana’s territory would be transferred to Havana. Additionally, upon approval of the Agreement, there will be two Talquin distribution lines remaining in Havana’s territory that would not be transferred, including 1. A short electric line segment along Iron Bridge Road (found on Map Page 7), and 2. A longer electric line segment currently serving a Talquin customer, as discussed in Section 2.4.

Pursuant to Section 5.1, the 2026 Territorial Agreement, if approved, would remain in effect for 30 years from the date the Commission issues its consummating order approving the agreement in its entirety. Upon the expiration of the initial 30-year term, the agreement will automatically renew for successive five-year terms, unless either party provides written notice of termination to the other party no fewer than 18 months prior to the effective date of the termination.

Proposed Boundary Changes

The joint petitioners assert that the proposed boundary line changes are primarily needed to align the territorial boundaries with the current parcel boundaries, which will provide the Utilities with greater certainty to plan or growth and avoid future disputes as the area surrounding Havana continues to grow. Additionally, the joint petitioners assert future developments will benefit from the easy and efficiency of working with one utility to meet their electrical service requirements, therefore avoiding duplication of services and wasteful expenditures.[7]

The joint petitioners negotiated and are proposing boundary line changes, in part, as a corrective measure to address extra-territorial customers each party identified in their respective territories.[8] While collaborating, the joint petitioners discovered some of the inadvertent connections while analyzing the territorial service boundaries related to the instant pleading.

Some of the proposed boundary line changes address the 24 extra-territorial customer connections (21 extra-territorial Havana customers in Talquin’s territory and 3 extra-territorial Talquin customers in Havana’s territory) that are not subject to transfer due to the uneconomic cost of switching utility facilities. Instead, the Utilities have agreed to modify their service territory boundaries to eliminate service to these extra-territorial customers. Per the 2026 Territorial Agreement, the modified boundaries will not eliminate Talquin’s service to the current Talquin customer located in Havana, even though that customer will reside within Havana’s service area.[9]

The joint petitioners conducted a recent review of the Havana and Talquin facilities along Conyers Street and identified some safety issues primarily related to telecommunication attachments and their proximity to the utilities’ electrical lines.[10] In a follow-up response, the joint petitioners stated that these safety issues have been addressed.[11]

Proposed Customer Transfers, Notifications, and Bills

No customer transfers are proposed in the 2026 Territorial Agreement. As such, the guidelines of Rule 25-6.0440(1)(d), F.A.C., regarding notification of customers to be transferred does not apply in this instance. Thus, the Utilities did not issue any notifications or bill comparisons.

The proposed Agreement includes specific language in Section 2.4, which applies to a current Talquin customer that will become extra-territorial under the proposed 2026 Territorial Agreement. The Utilities agreed that the residential customer receiving service will become extra-territorial until one of three conditions are met: (1) the customer requests a service change from Talquin to Havana, (2) the residence being served by Talquin is sold, assigned, or otherwise transferred, or (3) a new customer applies for service at the address. Upon this transfer of service from Talquin to Havana, Talquin will remove all facilities providing service to this address or sell them for the amount calculated in Section 3.3.[12]

Primary Staff Review

Primary staff analyzed the 2026 Territorial Agreement for compliance with each component of Rule 25-6.0440(2), F.A.C. Primary staff notes that while no specific purchase price was provided, the joint petitioners do address the method of setting a compensation amount for asset transfers based on replacement cost. Specifically, Talquin will transfer two electric lines and associated facilities to Havana using the method found in Section 3.3 of the proposed Agreement. The joint petitioners also assert that the transfer will allow Havana to avoid the significant expenses of installing new facilities.[13] Primary staff believes the facility purchase arrangements per the Agreement are acceptable.

Primary staff also evaluated the agreement according to Rule 25-6.0440(2)(b), F.A.C., which addresses electrical system reliability for existing or future customers. The joint petitioners assert the approval of the 2026 Territorial Agreement is not expected to result in a decrease in reliability to existing or future customers of either utility. The joint petitioners contend that the reliability of service to existing or future Talquin or Havana customers would not decline because of the proposed Agreement.

Under the 2026 Territorial Agreement, the joint petitioners have conceded that the current configuration may constitute uneconomic duplication, but argue that the 2026 Territorial Agreement, as proposed, will ensure that any uneconomic duplication will not further expand or continue forever. The current customer residing in Havana has been a Talquin customer for more than 50 years and the joint petitioners have determined that Talquin’s continued service to this location was reasonable and would not result in uneconomic duplication for an indefinite period of time.[14]

The joint petitioners stated that at least five years is expected to pass before future uneconomic duplication would occur (including expenses such as routine maintenance, tree trimming, and pole inspections) for the facilities serving the Havana customer.[15] Primary staff believes any potential uneconomic duplication proposed under the 2026 Territorial Agreement is not a strong argument favoring disapproval, provided the Utilities follow the condition attached to staff’s recommended approval. The 2026 Territorial Agreement provides for conditions as to when the account would be transferred from Havana to Quincy. Primary staff weighed these circumstances against the agreement’s broader benefits, including correcting other extra-territorial connections, transferring facilities, and establishing clearer boundaries to avoid future duplication and disputes.

On balance, primary staff finds that the 2026 Territorial Agreement, including its limited exception for one customer with unique circumstances, is reasonable and particular to this case. Primary staff also believes Commission approval of this agreement will not recognize customer preference or longevity alone as sufficient grounds for an exception; any future proposal would require its own public-interest evaluation.

The Utilities addressed the subject of existing facilities in the area of Conyers Street and 1st Street, where the Talquin and Havana each have overhead electric facilities on opposite sides of the streets. The joint petitioners stated that they believe the current configuration is safe and reliable.[16] The joint petitioners further explained that the poles of both Utilities are the appropriate distance from the roadway in accordance with the requirements from the Florida Department of Transportation, and both Utilities believe their respective facilities meet the requirements of the National Electric Safety Code (NESC) and, therefore, there is no negative impact on the safety experienced by vehicular traffic, pedestrians, and residents in the area.[17] Based on the responses provided by the Utilities, primary staff believes that the presence of duplicative facilities does not appear to present safety issues along Conyers Street and 1st Street. The placement of Talquin’s and Havana’s overhead lines and poles is shown in the supplemental response provided by the Utilities.[18]

Primary staff acknowledges that Section 2.4 is an agreement the Utilities forged, although primary staff believes acceptance of the proposed 2026 Territorial Agreement should be accompanied with a reporting obligation. Primary staff believes requiring a reporting obligation as a condition of approval will provide the Commission with a clear record of when the triggering events contemplated by Section 2.4 have occurred. Because there is uncertainty about when such events that would trigger the transfer of service may occur, primary staff believes it is reasonable to require that Talquin inform the Commission when Section 2.4 is triggered and it discontinues service to its customer in Havana, and all related facilities are de-energized. Primary staff believes this notification will help ensure that the potential for continued extra-territorial service and associated uneconomic duplication does not extend beyond the circumstances contemplated by the 2026 Territorial Agreement.

Primary Conclusion

The Commission should approve the 2026 Territorial Agreement between Talquin and Havana in Gadsden County, as consistent with the Standards for Approval set forth in Rule 25-6.0440(2), F.A.C. The 2026 Territorial Agreement, if approved, amends the respective boundary lines between the Utilities, thereby eliminating most extra-territorial connections. The Agreement would also facilitate the joint petitioners’ efforts to avoid uneconomic duplication of service facilities, wasteful expenditures, and hazardous conditions, as well as the transfer of two electric lines with associated facilities from Talquin to Havana. Additionally, the territorial boundary changes will provide the joint petitioners with greater certainty to plan for growth and avoid future disputes. Talquin should be required to notify the Commission in writing within 30 days of the date it permanently discontinues electric service to the residence in Havana. 

Alternative Staff Review

Alternate staff does not support approving the 2026 Territorial Agreement, for reasons set forth below. In Section 2.4 of the 2026 Territorial Agreement, the joint petitioners proposed an arrangement for a specific Talquin residential customer located within the proposed territorial boundary of Havana. In part, Section 2.4 states:

 

 . . . The Parties agree that COOPERATIVE [Talquin] may continue to serve its current Member with service located at 902 1st Street, Havana, Florida (the “1st Street Service Location”) until one of the following occurs: (i) the Member requests to become a customer of TOWN [Havana], (ii) the 1st Street Service Location is sold, assigned, or otherwise transferred, or (iii) a New Customer applies for service at the 1st Street Service Location. Upon transferring service to TOWN, the COOPERATIVE must either remove all facilities within the TOWN’S Territorial Area previously used for providing electric service to the 1st Street Service Location or sell the facilities to TOWN for the amount calculated in Section 3.3. . ..

 

Alternate staff believes the provisions in Section 2.4 appear to be counter to previously Commission-approved territorial agreements in one important respect:  the Commission has not approved a territorial agreement that, in effect, creates an extra-territorial customer for an indefinite period of time. In previous decisions, the Commission has allowed utilities to address transfer arrangements for existing extra-territorial customers over a set period of time. However, the instant case involves a customer who is currently not extra-territorial but would become one as a result of the proposed boundary change.

 

The joint petitioners assert that the negotiated language in Section 2.4 recognizes the age of the Talquin customer in Havana, as well as the customer’s longevity as a Talquin member (more than 50 years).[19] In response to a data request, the joint petitioners acknowledge Talquin’s facilities are located on the east side and Havana’s are located on the west side of Conyers Street in Havana, Florida. Talquin’s facilities currently serve the Havana customer and consists of approximately 1,380 feet of single phase primary line (two conductors for a total of 2,760 feet of energized conductors).[20] The joint petitioners contend that approval of the 2026 Territorial Agreement “would not result in permanent uneconomic duplication for an indefinite period of time.”[21] Alternate staff notes that this acknowledgement of uneconomic duplication of services is concerning for several reasons.

 

First, the acknowledgement of existing uneconomic duplication by the joint petitioners is in conflict with the specific references noted earlier in Rule 25-6.0440(2)(c) F.A.C., which allows the Commission to consider “the reasonable likelihood that the agreement will eliminate existing or potential uneconomic duplication of facilities.” Alternative staff notes that the joint petitioner’s boundary redraw for the Conyers Street location, thereby transferring service area from Talquin to Havana, is an essential step in eliminating the uneconomic duplication the utilities recognize exists. However, the inclusion of Section 2.4 of the proposed 2026 Territorial Agreement makes the redraw meaningless for purposes of eliminating uneconomic duplication for an undetermined period of time. Although Section 2.4 is a negotiated term like others in the 2026 Territorial Agreement, the language contained in Section 2.4 does not appear to “eliminate existing” uneconomic duplication as referenced in the rule. Instead, alternate staff believes the provisions in Section 2.4 of the 2026 Territorial Agreement effectively creates an extra-territorial customer.

 

Second, alternate staff considered the specific ways in which duplicated services would continue to be uneconomic in the future. Talquin acknowledged the on-going expenses to inspect and maintain the facilities serving the customer located in Havana. In response to a data request, Talquin asserts its next tree trimming cycle will be in the 2030-2032 timeframe, and its expenditures for the last trim cycle were about $7,250 for the pole line near Conyers Street. Talquin stated the most recent expense for routine pole inspections were about $400, and that expense will reoccur in about the same time frame as the tree trimming.[22] In addition to these scheduled maintenance costs, other costs related to equipment failure or accidents may also impact the expenses required to keep the electric line energized going forward. Accounting for the expenses associated with tree trimming, pole inspections, and potential equipment failure and/or accidents, it would be more cost-effective to address the issue of uneconomic duplication at this time. Talquin states the removal of the facilities would approximately take one month to schedule and complete, costing approximately $3,600.[23] Meanwhile, Havana could connect the customer by installing a service drop.23

 

Alternative Conclusion

All aspects of the proposed 2026 Territorial Agreement between Talquin and Havana in Gadsden County are appropriate except for Section 2.4, which would allow Talquin to provide electric service for an unspecified amount of time to an address located in Havana’s service area until one of three conditions are met. This exception to compliance with the proposed boundary lines contemplated in Section 2.4 may result in continued uneconomic duplication in the immediate geographic area for an unspecified period, such that the Agreement represents a detriment to the public interest. After providing required transfer notification and comparative utility rate information to the customer in Havana, the joint petitioners should be required to submit a revision to the proposed 2026 Territorial Agreement that is exclusive of the provisions contained in Section 2.4.
Issue 2: 

 Should this docket be closed?

Recommendation: 

 If the Commission approves the primary staff recommendation, and if no protest is filed by a person whose substantial interests are affected within 21 days of the issuance of the Order, this docket should be closed upon the issuance of a Consummating Order. If the Commission approves the alternative staff recommendation, this docket should remain open until the Commission’s disposition of a revised 2026 Territorial Agreement. (Crawford, Rauch) 

Staff Analysis: 

 If the Commission approves the primary staff recommendation, and if no protest is filed by a person whose substantial interests are affected within 21 days of the issuance of the Order, this docket should be closed upon the issuance of a Consummating Order. If the Commission approves the alternative staff recommendation, this docket should remain open until the Commission’s disposition of a revised 2026 Territorial Agreement.


 

 

 

 

 

 



[1] Order No. PSC-06-0341-PAA, issued April 24, 2006, in Docket No. 060034-EU, In re: Joint Petition for approval of territorial agreement in Gadsden County.

[2] Document No. 06685-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s First Data Request, No. 1.

[3] Document No. 06685-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s First Data Request, No. 4(a).

[4]Utilities Commission of the City of New Smyrna Beach v. Florida Public Service Commission, 469 So. 2d 731 (Fla. 1985).

[5] Document No. 06685-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s First Data Request, No. 1.

[6] Document No. 05336-2026, filed August 20, 2026, in Docket No. 202601013-EU, In re: Joint petition for approval of amended and restated territorial agreement in Gadsden County, by Talquin Electric Cooperative and Town of Havana, Exhibit B.

[7] Document No. 06685-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s First Data Request, No. 1.

[8] Document No. 06685-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s First Data Request, No. 2.

[9] Document No. 06685-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s First Data Request, No. 4.

[10] Document No. 06685-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s First Data Request, No. 5(d).

[11] Document No. 07362-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s Second Data Request, No. 5.

[12] Document No. 05336-2026, filed August 20, 2026, in Docket No. 202601013-EU, In re: Joint petition for approval of amended and restated territorial agreement in Gadsden County, by Talquin Electric Cooperative and Town of Havana, Section 2.4.

[13] Document No. 06685-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s First Data Request, No. 6.

[14] Document No. 06685-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s First Data Request, No. 5.

[15] Document No. 07362-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s Second Data Request, No. 2.

[16] Document No. 06685-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s First Data Request, No. 4.

[17] Document No. 07362-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s Second Data Request, No. 6.

[18] Document No. 07001-2026, joint petitioners’ supplement response to Staff’s First Data Request, No. 5(d).

[19] Document No. 06685-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s First Data Request, No. 4(a).

[20] Document No. 06685-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s First Data Request, No. 5(d), and Document No. 07362-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s Second Data Request, No. 1(a).

[21] Document No. 06685-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s First Data Request, No. 4(a).

[22] Document No. 07362-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s Second Data Request, Nos. 1(b). and 1(c).

[23] Document No. 07362-2026, joint petitioners’ response to Staff’s Second Data Request, No. 3.