State of Florida

pscSEAL

 

Public Service Commission

Capital Circle Office Center ● 2540 Shumard Oak Boulevard
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0850

-M-E-M-O-R-A-N-D-U-M-

 

DATE:

November 17, 2026

TO:

Office of Commission Clerk (Teitzman)

FROM:

Division of Economics (Ward)

Division of Engineering (Brown, Graves)

Office of the General Counsel (Brownless)

RE:

Docket No. 20260136-GU – Petition for approval of 2025 true-up, projected 2026 true-up; and 2027 revenue requirements and surcharges associated with cast iron/bare steel pipe replacement rider; and request to extend rider from 1/28 through 12/31, by Peoples Gas System, Inc.

AGENDA:

12/01/26 – Regular Agenda – Tariff Filing – Interested Persons May Participate

COMMISSIONERS ASSIGNED:

All Commissioners

PREHEARING OFFICER:

Administrative

CRITICAL DATES:

05/01/27 (8-Month Effective Date)

SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS:

None

 

 Case Background

On September 1, 2026, Peoples Gas System, Inc. (Peoples or utility) filed a petition for approval of its final 2025 true-up, projected 2026 true-up, and 2027 revenue requirement and surcharges associated with the cast iron/bare steel replacement rider (CI/BSR Rider or rider). Additionally, Peoples requested to extend the rider from January 1, 2028, to December 31, 2031. In a letter dated October 22, 2026, Peoples filed a letter with an attached revised Exhibit H that replaced the Exhibit H filed in the original petition.[1]

The rider was originally approved by Order No. PSC-12-0476-TRF-GU (2012 Order) to recover the cost of accelerating the replacement of cast iron and bare steel pipes through a surcharge on customers’ bills over a 10-year period, with replacement projects being completed by the end of 2022.[2] In addition, replaced infrastructure would roll in to rate base during a rate case and CI/BSR would be “reset to zero.” By Order No. PSC-17-0066-AS-GU, the Commission approved a comprehensive settlement agreement (2017 Agreement) between Peoples and the Office of Public Counsel that allowed the inclusion of problematic plastic pipe (PPP) to be an eligible replacement under the CI/BSR beginning in 2017 and continuing through December 31, 2027.[3]

In December 2023, the Commission approved Peoples’ petition for rate increase, which contained two provisions that would impact the CI/BSR Rider.[4] First, Peoples moved its CI/BSR investments as of December 31, 2023, into rate base, as required by the 2012 Order approving the rider and the surcharge was set to zero. Second, the Commission approved Peoples’ request for the Long-Term Debt Cost Rate (LTDR) true-up mechanism, which allowed Peoples to make a one-time adjustment to the estimated cost of long-term debt for the projected test year ending December 31, 2024.[5] The Commission approved the recovery of any incremental revenue requirement from the LTDR greater than $500,000 through the CI/BSR Rider.

Peoples’ last rate case was in 2025 and was settled with a stipulation and settlement agreement (2025 Agreement), which was approved by Order No. PSC-2025-0413-S-GU.[6] Pursuant to paragraph 3(a) of the 2025 Agreement, $6,733,295 of CI/BSR revenues were transferred into base rates. Additionally, pursuant to paragraph 5(b) of the 2025 Agreement, Peoples is prohibited from seeking recovery through the CI/BSR any PPP costs associated with the Tampa Downtown project or any other PPP costs included for recovery in the 2025 rate case filing.

During the review process of the utility’s petition, staff issued two data requests, for which responses were received on October 19, 2026, and November 3, 2026, respectively. By Order No. PSC-2026-0382-PCO-GU, the petition was suspended to allow staff a sufficient opportunity to gather and evaluate all pertinent information related to the tariff proposals in order to present the Commission with an informed recommendation.[7] The Commission has jurisdiction over this matter pursuant to Sections 366.03, 366.04, 366.05, and 366.06, Florida Statutes (F.S.).


Discussion of Issues

Issue 1: 

 Should the Commission approve Peoples' proposed CI/BSR Rider extension from January 1, 2028, to December 31, 2031?

Recommendation: 

 Yes, the Commission should approve Peoples’ proposed CI/BSR Rider extension from January 1, 2028, to December 31, 2031. Staff believes the CI/BSR Rider extension proposal is reasonable and that accelerated replacement of PPP is in the best interest of the utility and its customers due to its unique safety risk. (Ward, Graves)

Staff Analysis: 

 

Rider Extension Request

In its petition, Peoples listed three reasons for why the proposed CI/BSR Rider extension is needed. First, the utility stated that since it began PPP replacement in 2017, it has continued to discover additional PPP in its system that was not included in its initial estimate. The utility stated that these discoveries typically involved small sections of pipe and occurred in portions of the utility’s system that were acquired from another utility and for which records are incomplete. In response to staff’s second data request, Peoples provided a list of portions of the system with incomplete records that included the utility they were acquired from and the year they were acquired. Peoples also explained that to identify sections of pipe in these portions of the system with incomplete records it performs manual reviews of records that may be in its Geographical Information System, but not associated with specific attributes.

Additionally, the utility stated that it discovered 82 miles of PPP infrastructure in unique circumstances. In response to staff’s first data request, Peoples explained that 62 miles of the additional PPP was identified in its Jacksonville service area through a review of infrastructure in the service area.[8] The utility stated that this review determined that these facilities were previously misidentified as non-problematic due to a time/date stamp conversion error. The utility stated that it also identified 20 miles of PPP in its’ Panama City service area during design work for a project on the system. Peoples explained that during the design work, records were reviewed, and it was determined that certain facilities did not have installation dates associated with them. The utility stated that, through further research, it determined the facilities were PPP installed prior to 1984.

The second reason that Peoples listed as to why the CI/BSR Rider extension is needed is that the utility’s replacement schedule has experienced delays due to factors outside of the utility’s control. In its petition, Peoples stated that construction delays and labor shortages slowed the company’s ability to timely complete its scheduled PPP replacement projects. Additionally, the utility stated that long lead times in obtaining easement, permit, and railroad approvals interfered with the utility’s replacement project workflow.

The final reason the utility believes the CI/BSR Rider extension is needed is that an extension will allow the utility to prudently complete the remaining PPP replacement work while continuing to advance the safety objectives underlying the rider. In its petition, Peoples stated that the concern about premature brittle-like cracking of plastic pipe manufactured and used for gas service before 1983 that served as the basis for including PPP as an eligible replacement remains a safety risk today. The utility stated that the continued accelerated replacement of PPP with modern materials that have a longer useful life is in the public interest and in the best interests of the utility and its customers.

Scope of the Rider Extension

In its petition, Peoples stated that it estimates 150 miles of PPP infrastructure will remain in its system when the current PPP program expires on December 31, 2027. The utility explained that most of this infrastructure will be located in Panama City (approximately 32 miles), St. Petersburg (approximately 37 miles), and Jacksonville (approximately 59 miles). A map depicting the six service areas where replacement projects will occur during the extension period and the estimated miles in each area was included in the petition as Exhibit F.

In paragraph 23 of the petition, the utility stated that the workplan for the four-year extension includes four years of PPP replacement projects targeting an annual average of 46 miles for the first three years, with 11 miles to be completed in the fourth year. Peoples stated that this activity is dependent upon permitting approvals from municipalities, the Florida Department of Transportation, railroads, and other third parties that can materially impact when individual projects can proceed. The utility explained that the fourth year of the extension period serves as a prudent contingency period to address unavoidable project delays, complete restoration work, facilitate the efficient deployment of contractor resources, and allow for the replacement of any additional PPP infrastructure discovered during the extension period. In response to staff’s first data request, Peoples stated that it would seek to recover the associated replacement costs of any additional PPP discovered during the period eligible for recovery under the rider.[9]

Conclusion

Staff recommends that the Commission approve Peoples’ proposed CI/BSR Rider extension from January 1, 2028, to December 31, 2031. Staff believes the CI/BSR Rider extension proposal is reasonable and that accelerated replacement of PPP is in the best interest of the utility and its customers due to its unique safety risk.


Issue 2: 

 Should the Commission approve Peoples' proposed CI/BSR Rider surcharges for the period January through December 2027

Recommendation: 

 Yes, the Commission should approve Peoples’ proposed CI/BSR Rider surcharges to be effective for the first billing cycle of January through the last billing cycle of December 2027. Staff has reviewed Peoples’ filings and supporting documentation and believes that the calculations are consistent with the methodology approved in the 2012 Order and are reasonable and accurate. (Ward)

Staff Analysis: 

 The CI/BSR Rider surcharges have been in effect since January 2013 and were projected to be in effect for 10 years with replacement projects completed by the end of 2022. In a response to staff’s first data request in the 2024 docket, Peoples stated that the COVID-19 pandemic environment greatly contributed to replacement efforts going beyond the 10-year period.[10] Contributing factors include construction contractor labor shortages, consulting firm availability, supply chain challenges, and extensive permitting challenges. The utility stated that multiple CI/BSR projects in Dade-Broward incurred continued delays in 2025 due to construction moratoriums and lengthy permitting processes. Peoples stated that some PPP projects also experienced delays in 2025, with some projects delayed or continuing into 2026.

In 2026, Peoples’ cast iron/bare steel replacement activity focused in Dade and Broward Counties. Peoples stated that some of this work required activities to confirm that the pipe material is cast iron or bare steel. Peoples’ 2026 PPP replacement activity focused in the areas of Dade-Broward, St. Petersburg, Orlando, Lakeland, Daytona, Jacksonville, Panama City, and Jupiter. For 2027, Peoples stated it will continue working through all the remaining known CI/BSR projects, including completing any remaining verification necessary to confirm the material.

Peoples stated it will continue the design and permitting of PPP replacement projects in the areas of St. Petersburg, Orlando, Daytona, Jacksonville, Panama City, Eustis, and Dade-Broward, releasing projects to construction as plans and permits become available. Peoples provided a detailed description of the projects in response to staff’s first data request.[11] Attachment A to this recommendation contains Table 1, which consolidates actual and projected CI/BSR and PPP miles, replaced investment, and revenue requirements for each year of the replacement program.[12] Additionally, Peoples provided tables that display the replacement progress and forecasts for the CI/BSR Rider (Table 2) and for PPP (Table 3).[13]

True-ups by Year

Peoples’ calculation for the 2027 revenue requirement and surcharges includes a final true-up for 2025, an actual/estimated true-up for 2026, and projected costs for 2027. Pursuant to the 2012 Order, the capital expenditures for 2026 and 2027 exclude the first $1 million of facility replacements each year because that amount is included in rate base. Peoples has included depreciation expense savings as discussed in the 2012 Order; however, the utility has not identified any operations and maintenance savings.

Final True-up for 2025

Exhibit A of the petition shows that the revenues collected for 2025 were $3,631,812 compared to a revenue requirement of $2,842,283, resulting in an over-recovery of $789,529. The final 2024 under-recovery of $331,724, 2025 over-recovery of $789,529, and interest associated with any over- and under-recoveries ($15,675), results in a total 2025 over-recovery of $473,480. In response to staff’s first data request, Peoples explained that three factors led to the 2025 over-recovery.[14] First, higher therm sales than projected resulted in higher revenues collected. Second, less infrastructure replacement investment than projected resulted in a lower return on investment. Lastly, variances between projected in-service dates and actual in-service dates resulted in lower depreciation than projected.

Actual/Estimated 2026 True-up

In Exhibit B of the petition, Peoples provided actual revenues for January through July and forecast revenues for August through December of 2026, totaling $3,243,014, compared to an actual/estimated revenue requirement of $1,767,967, resulting in an over-recovery of $1,475,047. The final 2025 over-recovery of $473,480, 2026 over-recovery of $1,475,047, and interest associated with any over- and under-recoveries ($65,332), results in a total 2026 over-recovery of $2,013,859.

Projected 2027 Costs

Exhibit C of the petition shows Peoples projects investments or capital expenditures of $75,992,318 for the replacement of cast iron/bare steel infrastructure and PPP in 2027, excluding the $1 million adjustment to rate base. The return on investment, depreciation expense (less savings), and property tax expense associated with that investment are $10,259,222. After adding the total 2026 over-recovery of $2,013,859, the total 2027 revenue requirement is $8,245,363. Table 1-1 displays the 2027 revenue requirement calculation. In response to staff’s first data request, Peoples provided updated investment and revenue requirement projections for CI/BSR and PPP which is contained in Table 1 of Attachment A.

Table 1-1

2027 CI/BSR Rider Revenue Requirement

2027 Projected Expenditures

$75,992,318

Return on Investment

$8,297,941

Depreciation Expense (less savings)

1,265,687

Property Tax Expense

695,594

2027 Revenue Requirement

$10,259,222

Less 2026 Over-recovery

2,013,859

Total 2027 Revenue Requirement

$8,245,363

Source: Page 2 of 2 in Exhibit C in petition (Docket No. 20260136-GU)

Proposed Surcharges

As established in the 2012 Order, the total 2027 revenue requirement is allocated to rate classes using the same methodology that was used for the allocation of mains and services in the cost of service study used in Peoples’ most recently approved rate case. After calculating the percentage of total plant costs attributed to each rate class, the respective percentages were multiplied by the 2027 revenue requirement resulting in the revenue requirement by rate class. Dividing each rate class’s revenue requirement by projected therm sales provides the rider surcharge for each rate class.

If the Commission approves this recommendation, the proposed 2027 rider surcharge for residential customers would be $0.04342 per therm (compared to the current surcharge of $0.01593). The 2027 monthly bill impact would be $0.87 for a residential customer who uses 20 therms. The proposed tariff sheet, as filed in the amended petition, is provided in this recommendation as Attachment B.

Conclusion

Staff recommends that the Commission approve Peoples’ proposed CI/BSR Rider surcharges to be effective for the first billing cycle of January through the last billing cycle of December 2027. Staff has reviewed Peoples’ filings and supporting documentation and believes that the calculations are consistent with the methodology approved in the 2012 Order and are reasonable and accurate.

 


Issue 3: 

 Should this docket be closed?

Recommendation: 

 Yes. If Issue 1 is approved and a protest is filed within 21 days of the issuance of the order, the tariff should remain in effect, with any revenues held subject to refund, pending resolution of the protest. If no timely protest is filed, this docket should be closed upon the issuance of a consummating order. (Brownless)

Staff Analysis: 

 If Issue 1 is approved and a protest is filed within 21 days of the issuance of the order, the tariff should remain in effect, with any revenues held subject to refund, pending resolution of the protest. If no timely protest is filed, this docket should be closed upon the issuance of a consummating order.


Table 1

Peoples’ CI/BSR Replacement Program Progress

Year

CI/BS Miles Replaced

PPP Miles Replaced

CI/BS Investmentͣ

PPP Investmentᵇ

CI/BS Revenue Requirement

PPP Revenue Requirement

2017

51

-

$17,588,366

$2,915,802

$6,868,302

$74,021

2018

62

56

$27,035,678

$15,890,424

$8,510,823

$848,201

2019

52

42

$35,821,371

$17,425,589

$11,075,229

$2,706,161

2020

55

43

$32,317,184

$11,115,571

$14,817,804

$4,358,010

2021

14

38

$23,726,642

$19,812,603

$1,347,321ͨ

($160,452)ͨ

2022

10.4

29

$13,079,280

$15,486,397

$3,120,580

$1,899,547

2023

2.3

44

$5,815,954

$18,210,943

$3,927,032

$3,604,313

2024

2.4

10

$5,798,611

$15,279,982

$224,372ͩ

$382,518ͩ

2025

1.7

14.8

$2,758,012

$25,061,299

$672,129

$2,170,154

2026*

1.4

55.6

$2,574,720

$59,055,197

($158,312)ͤ

$1,926,278ͤ

2027*

6.0

59.7

$11,160,404

$64,831,914

$749,081

$9,510,141

2028*

ᶠ

49.8

ᶠ

$49,211,981

$1,538,009

$16,486,971

2029*

ᶠ

49.8

ᶠ

$41,645,419

$1,542,512

$21,819,336

2030*

ᶠ

39.5

ᶠ

$33,512,447

$1,527,561

$26,115,779

2031*

ᶠ

11.0

ᶠ

$13,119,878

$1,514,886ᶢ

$28,744,324

* Projected

ͣ Cast Iron/Bare Steel (CI/BS) Investment includes removal of initial $1 million for years prior to and including 2025.

ᵇ PPP Investment includes removal of initial $1 million for years after 2025.

ͨ Revenue requirement based on current year investment only as investment for prior years was rolled into rate base pursuant to the 2020 rate case.

ͩ Revenue requirement based on current year investment only as investment for prior years was rolled into rate base pursuant to the 2023 rate case.

ͤ Revenue Requirement based on current year investment only as investment for prior years was rolled into rate base pursuant to the 2025 rate case.

ᶠ Peoples’ petition for extension of the Rider CI/BSR does not include any miles replaced and associated investment for CI/BS pipe replacement during the extension years.

ᶢ The revenue requirement for CI/BS was excluded from Schedule H of the utility’s petition filed in this docket. The utility will file a revised Schedule H.


 

Table 2

Peoples’ CI/BSR Replacement Progress

Year

Main Replacements (miles)

Service Line Replacements (count)

Replaced CI

Replaced BS

Remaining CI

Remaining BS

Remaining CI/BS

Replaced

Remaining

2012

-

-

100

354

454

-

14,978

2013

13

38

87

316

403

907

14,071

2014

2

15

85

298 ͣ

383

7,964

6,107

2015

26

60

59

238

297

1,019

5,088

2016

15

35

44

203

247

1,050

6,963ᵇ

2017

15

36

29

178 ͣ

207

1,135

4,279ᵇ

2018

10

52

18 ͣ

126

144

1,970

2,309

2019

8

44

10

83 ͣ

93

649

1,660

2020

4

51

6

35 ͣ

41

423

1,237

2021

3.5

10.5

2 ͣ

24 ͣ

26

191

1,089ᵇ

2022

1.3

9.1

0.9 ͣ

14.6 ͣ

15.5

74

994ᵇ

2023

0.3

2.0

0.6

12.4 ͣ

13

25

941ᵇ

2024

0.1

2.3

0.3 ͣ

5.6 ͣ

5.9

97

807ᵇ

2025

0

1.7

0.3

7.6

7.9

34

709ᵇ

2026*

0

1.4

0.3

6.2

6.5

Tbd

Tbd

2027*

0

6

0.3

0.2

0.5

Tbd

Tbd

2028

ͨ

ͨ

ͨ

ͨ

ͨ

Tbd

Tbd

2029

ͨ

ͨ

ͨ

ͨ

ͨ

Tbd

Tbd

2030

ͨ

ͨ

ͨ

ͨ

ͨ

Tbd

Tbd

2031

ͨ

ͨ

ͨ

ͨ

ͨ

Tbd

Tbd

* Projected

ͣ Miles of pipe added or subtracted after reclassification or identification.

ᵇ Service lines added or subtracted after reclassification or identification.

ͨ Peoples’ petition for extension of the Rider CI/BSR does not include any miles replaced and associated investment for CI/BS pipe replacement during the extension years.


 

Table 3

Peoples’ PPP Replacement Program Progress

Year

Main Replacements (miles)

Service Line Replacements (count)

Replaced PPP Mains

Remaining PPP Mains

Replaced PPP Service Lines

Remaining PPP Service Lines

2017

-

509

1,396

26,841

2018

56

461 ͣ

3,941

24,741ᵇ

2019

42

419 ͣ

2,349

20,420ᵇ

2020

43

370 ͣ

1,702

18,718

2021

38

337 ͣ

882

17,683ᵇ

2022

29

306 ͣ

837

17,229ᵇ

2023

44

281 ͣ

883

16,346

2024

10

296 ͣ

637

15,499ᵇ

2025

14.8

265.3 ͣ

599

14,901ᵇ

2026*

55.6

209.8

Tbd

Tbd

2027*

59.7

150.4

Tbd

Tbd

2028*

49.8

100.2

Tbd

Tbd

2029*

49.8

50.5

Tbd

Tbd

2030*

39.5

11

Tbd

Tbd

2031*

11

0

Tbd

Tbd

* Projected

ͣ Miles of pipe added or subtracted after reclassification or identification.

ᵇ Service lines added or subtracted after reclassification or identification.


 

Text, letter

AI-generated content may be incorrect.



[1] DN 07484-2026.

[2]  Order No. PSC-12-0476-TRF-GU, issued September 18, 2012, in Docket No. 20110320-GU, In re: Petition for approval of Cast iron/Bare Steel Pipe Replacement Rider (Rider CI/BSR), by Peoples Gas System.

[3] Order No. PSC-17-0066-AS-GU, issued February 28, 2017, in Docket No. 20160159-GU, In re: Petition for approval of settlement agreement pertaining to Peoples Gas System’s 2016 depreciation study, environmental reserve account, problematic plastic pipe replacement, and authorized ROE.

[4] Order No. PSC-2023-0388-FOF-GU, issued December 27, 2023, in Docket No. 20230023-GU, In re: Petition for

rate increase by Peoples Gas System, Inc.

[5] See pages 107-109 of Order No. PSC-2023-0388-FOF-GU.

[6] Order No. PSC-2025-0413-S-GU, issued October 31, 2025, in Docket No. 20250029-GU, In re: Petition for rate increase, by Peoples Gas System, Inc.

[7] Order No. PSC-2026-0382-PCO-GU, issued October 26, 2026, in Docket No. 20260136-GU, In re: Petition for approval of 2025 true-up, projected 2026 true-up; and 2027 revenue requirements and surcharges associated with cast iron/bare steel pipe replacement rider; and request to extend rider from 1/28 through 12/31, by Peoples Gas System, Inc.

[8] DN 07422-2026, response No. 16.

[9] DN 07422-2026, response No. 12.

[10] DN 09444-2024, response No. 4.

[11] DN 07422-2026, response No. 5.

 

 

[14] DN 07422-2026, response No. 9.