State of Florida

pscSEAL

 

Public Service Commission

Capital Circle Office Center ● 2540 Shumard Oak Boulevard
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0850

-M-E-M-O-R-A-N-D-U-M-

 

DATE:

November 17, 2026

TO:

Office of Commission Clerk (Teitzman)

FROM:

Division of Economics (Bethea, Bruce, McClelland)

Division of Accounting and Finance (Bardin, D. Buys, Maxwell, Sewards)

Division of Engineering (Ellis, Sanchez)

Office of the General Counsel (J. Crawford, Imig, Rauch)

RE:

Docket No. 20260039-WS – Application for increase in water and wastewater rates in Seminole County by Hometown Palm Valley, LLC d/b/a Palm Valley Utilities.

AGENDA:

12/01/26 – Regular Agenda – Decision on Suspension of Rates and Interim Rates – Participation is at the Discretion of the Commission

COMMISSIONERS ASSIGNED:

All Commissioners

PREHEARING OFFICER:

Ortega

CRITICAL DATES:

60-Day Suspension and Interim Date waived until 12/01/26

SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS:

None

 

 Case Background

Hometown Palm Valley, LLC. d/b/a Palm Valley Utilities (Palm Valley or Utility) is a Class B utility providing water and wastewater service to approximately 834 residential and 8 general service customers in Seminole County. The Utility’s last rate case was in 2009.[1] In 2025, Palm Valley recorded total company operating revenues of $219,078 for water and $547,914 for wastewater and operating expenses of $228,381 for water and $674,919 for wastewater.

On March 18, 2026, Palm Valley filed a letter requesting approval of a historic test year ended December 31, 2025, for its application for interim and final water and wastewater rate increases, which it anticipated filing no later than July 31, 2026. Subsequently, on June 18, 2026, the Utility filed a letter requesting an extension of the minimum filling requirements (MFRs) filing deadlines from July 31, 2026, to September 30, 2026. The Utility filed its MFRs on September 18, 2026. On October 16, 2026, staff sent the Utility a letter indicating deficiencies in the filing of its MFR, and the deadline to correct its deficiencies was November 16, 2026. The Utility filed its responses to the MFRs on November 9, 2026, which are currently being reviewed. To date, the Utility’s official filing date has not been established.

The Utility’s application for interim and final water and wastewater rates is based on the historical 13-month average period that ended December 31, 2025. Palm Valley is requesting rates sufficient to recover all expenses incurred by the Utility on a going-forward basis and provide a fair rate of return on its investment in property considered 100 percent used and useful in providing service.

The Utility requested interim rates designed to generate revenues of $299,473 for water and $775,295 for wastewater. This results in a revenue increase of $87,985, or 41.60 percent, for water and $221,973, or 40.12 percent, for wastewater. The Utility requested final rates designed to generate annual revenues of $483,023, for water and $1,758,360 for wastewater. This represents revenue increases of $271,535, or 128.39 percent for water, and $1,205,037, or 217.78 percent for wastewater.

The original 60-day statutory deadline for the Commission to suspend Palm Valley’s requested final rates and address its interim rate request was November 18, 2026. However, by letter dated September 28, 2026, and a clarifying letter dated October 19, 2026, the Utility agreed to extend the statutory time frame by which the Commission is required to address the suspension of Palm Valley’s final rates and its interim rate request, to December 1, 2026. This recommendation addresses the suspension of the Utility’s requested final rates and its requested interim rates. The Commission has jurisdiction pursuant to Sections 367.081, and 367.082, Florida Statutes (F.S.).

 


Discussion of Issues

Issue 1: 

 Should the Utility's proposed final water and wastewater rates be suspended?

Recommendation: 

 Yes, Palm Valley’s proposed final water and wastewater rates should be suspended. (Bethea)

Staff Analysis: 

 Section 367.081(6), F.S., provides that the Commission may, for good cause, withhold consent to the implementation of the requested rates within 60 days after the date the rate request is filed. Further, Section 367.081(10), F.S., permits the proposed rates to go into effect (secured and subject to refund) at the expiration of five months from the official date of filing if: (1) the Commission has not acted upon the requested rate increase; or (2) if the Commission’s PAA action is protested by a party other than the Utility.

Staff has reviewed the filing and has considered the information filed in support of the rate application and the proposed final rates. Staff believes that it is reasonable and necessary to require further elaboration and explanation regarding this data and to require the production of additional and/or corroborative data. To date, staff has initiated an audit of Palm Valley’s books and records. The audit report is tentatively due on January 12, 2027. Staff believes additional requests will be necessary to process this case. Based on the foregoing, staff recommends suspension of the Utility’s proposed rate increase.

 


Issue 2: 

 Should any interim revenue increase be approved?

Recommendation: 

 Yes, Palm Valley should be authorized to collect annual water and wastewater revenues as indicated below:

Adjusted Test

Year Revenues

 

$ Increase

Revenue

Requirement

 

% Increase

Water

$211,488

$96,815

$308,303

45.78%

Wastewater

$553,323

$232,660

$785,983

 42.05%

(Sewards)

Staff Analysis: 

 Pursuant to Section 367.082(1), F.S., the Commission may authorize the collection of interim rates during any proceeding for a change of rates upon petition from any party or on its own motion. To establish a prima facie entitlement for interim relief, the Utility shall demonstrate that it is earning outside the range of reasonableness on its rate of return. Pursuant to Section 367.082(2)(a), F.S., in a proceeding for an interim increase in rates, the Commission shall authorize, within 60 days of the filing for such relief, the collection of rates sufficient to earn the minimum of the range of return on equity (ROE) approved in the last rate proceeding.

On September 18, 2026, Palm Valley filed rate base, cost of capital, and operating income schedules to support its requested interim increase. Pursuant to Section 367.082(5)(b)1., F.S., the achieved rate of return for interim purposes must be calculated by applying adjustments consistent with those used in the Utility’s most recent rate proceeding and annualizing any rate changes. Staff reviewed Palm Valley’s interim request and Order No. PSC-2010-0606-PAA-WS, from its last rate case (2010 Rate Case Order).[2] Staff has attached accounting schedules to illustrate its recommended rate base, capital structure, and test year operating income amounts. The rate base schedules are labeled as Schedule Nos. 1-A, 1-B, and 1-C. The capital structure schedule is labeled Schedule No. 2. The operating income schedules are labeled as Schedule Nos. 3-A, 3-B, and 3-C. Staff’s recommended adjustments are discussed below.

Interim Rate Base

In its filing, the Utility calculated a rate base of $979,264 for the water system, and $1,286,591 for the wastewater system. Palm Valley adjusted used and useful (U&U) amounts based on non-used and useful percentages established in the Utility’s last rate case. Palm Valley also made working capital adjustments based on corresponding adjustments to operation and maintenance (O&M) expense. Staff believes additional adjustments to accumulated depreciation and working capital are necessary for interim purposes.

Accumulated Depreciation

In its MFRs, Palm Valley calculated an accumulated depreciation balance of $2,977 for Account No. 339.4, and a balance of $0 for Account No. 348.5. The Utility clarified the balance of $2,977 should be reclassified to Account No. 348.5.[3] This results in a net zero adjustment to accumulated depreciation for the water system.

Used & Useful

Staff reviewed the Utility’s interim U&U calculations on a per system basis. The review is based upon previous Commission decisions and available usage and capacity data contained in Palm Valley’s MFR schedules. Consistent with Commission practice, staff recommends no adjustments for all distribution and collection systems, storage, and reuse facilities that have been determined to be 100 percent U&U by the prior rate case order.[4] Staff also recommends no adjustments to the water treatment plant (WTP) and wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) U&U values of 78 percent and 81 percent respectively contained in Palm Valley’s interim rate base as approved in the prior rate case order.

Palm Valley made net non-U&U adjustments of $35,670 to the water system, and $180,501 to the wastewater system. Staff does not have any adjustment to these balances. As such, staff recommends net non-U&U adjustments of $35,670 to the water system, and $180,501 to the wastewater system.

Working Capital Allowance

Pursuant to Rule 25-30.433(3), Florida Administrative Code (F.A.C.), working capital allowance for Class B utilities is calculated using the formula method, which is one-eighth of O&M expenses. In its filing, Palm Valley reflected a total working capital allowance balance of $15,630 for the water system and $49,106 for the wastewater system. Based on staff’s recommended adjustments to O&M discussed below, staff has reduced working capital allowance by $126 for the water system and $224 for the wastewater system. Therefore, staff recommends a working capital allowance balance of $15,504 for the water system and $48,882 for the wastewater system.

Based on the above, staff recommends that Palm Valley’s interim rate base should be $979,138 for the water system and $1,286,367 for the wastewater system. The schedules for rate base are attached as Schedules 1-A, 1-B, and 1-C.

Interim Cost of Capital

In its filing, the Utility reflected an ROE of 9.76 percent on MFR interim schedule D-1. However, Palm Valley used a ROE of only 8.76 percent in its calculation of the revenue requirements. According to the 2010 Rate Case Order, the minimum of the Utility’s authorized range of return on equity is 9.76 percent. Pursuant to Section 367.082, F.S., an interim increase should be calculated using the minimum of the range of the ROE authorized in the Utility's last rate case. Staff reached out to the Utility and confirmed that its calculation using the lower ROE was an error. As such, staff recommends using the minimum of the range of the ROE established in the last order of 9.76 percent.

The Utility’s capital structure is a simple average derived from the prior year balance and the test year balance. The resulting capital structure was reconciled to rate base consistent with the Utility’s last rate case.

Based on an analysis of the MFRs and the 2010 Rate Case Order, and adjustments to rate base discussed above, staff recommends an overall rate of return of 9.76 percent. The schedule for cost of capital is attached as Schedule 2.

Interim Net Operating Income

In its filing, Palm Valley calculated test year revenues of $299,473 for water and $775,296 for wastewater. To calculate the appropriate amount of interim test year operating revenues, staff removed the Utility’s requested interim revenue increase of $87,985 from water and $221,973 from wastewater. Staff does not have any adjustment to the Utility’s interim test year revenues. Based on the above, staff recommends that the appropriate interim test year revenues, before any increase, are $211,488 for water and $553,323 for wastewater.

Operating Expenses

In its filing, the Utility calculated operating expenses of $213,690 for the water system, and $662,590 for the wastewater system. Palm Valley included adjustments to O&M expense, depreciation expense, and Taxes Other Than Income expense (TOTI). Staff believes additional adjustments to Operating Expenses are necessary for interim purposes.

 

O&M Expense

Palm Valley’s MFRs reflect an O&M expense of $125,039 for the water system, and $392,846 for the wastewater system. In its filing, the Utility proposed total decreases of $26,115 for the water system and $23,474 for the wastewater system. The majority of the adjustments were to reclassify expenses from one account to another, resulting in net zero adjustments. The Utility also included adjustments to remove RAFs and rate case expense incurred during the test year. Staff believes these are appropriate adjustments. Staff has further adjustments to chemicals expense and contractual services – other expense as discussed below.

 

Chemicals Expense

As part of its MFR schedules, Palm Valley included an adjustment for chemicals per dosage schedule in addition to the adjustment approved by the prior rate case order. This additional adjustment was not approved by the Commission.

 

Per Palm Valley’s last order, the Commission determined an excessive unaccounted water (EUW) reduction of 3 percent, and an inflow and infiltration (I&I) reduction of 19 percent should be made to the Utility’s chemicals and purchased power expenses.

 

In its MFRs, Palm Valley reflected chemicals expense of $15,809 for the water system and $31,616 for the wastewater system. This includes EUW and I&I adjustments to reduce chemicals expense by $516 for the water system, and $6,476 for the wastewater system. However, the calculations did not include the adjustment per dosage schedule discussed above. Staff has recalculated EUW and I&I based on chemicals expense including these adjustments. As such, staff recommends an adjustment to reduce the EUW adjustment to water by $26 and increase the I&I adjustment to wastewater by $761. This represents a total EUW adjustment of $490 to the water system and a total I&I adjustment of $7,237 to the wastewater system. As such, staff recommends total chemicals expense of $15,835 for the water system and $30,855 for the wastewater system.

 

Contractual Services – Other Expense

In its MFRs, the Utility included $52,138 and $223,312 in contractual services – other expense for the water and wastewater systems, respectively. Palm Valley included adjustments to increase contractual services – other by $1,030 for both the water and wastewater systems to account for two months of missing invoices for meter reading. However, staff believes these adjustments are improper for interim purposes. Rule 25-30.437(2)(d), F.A.C., states that for the utility to “demonstrate that it is earning outside the range of reasonableness” on its rate of return “the utility must submit schedules of rate base, cost of capital and net operating income on an historical basis, with all adjustments thereto.” Staff believes these adjustments would misrepresent the historical contractual services – other expenses that were incurred during the test year. Staff believes these adjustments are appropriate for consideration in the final rate increase but violate the nature of the interim process. As such, staff recommends removal of $1,030 from contractual services – other for both the water and wastewater systems.

 

Based on the adjustments above, staff recommends reducing O&M expense by $1,004 ($26 - $1,030) for the water system, and $1,791 (-$761 - $1,030) for the wastewater system. This reflects total recommended O&M expenses of $124,035 for the water system and $391,056 for the wastewater system.

 

Depreciation Expense

In its filing, the Utility reflected depreciation expense of $63,051 for the water system and $219,829 for the wastewater system. This included adjustments to decrease water depreciation expense by $2,053 and wastewater depreciation expense by $23,743 due to a corresponding non-U&U adjustment. Upon investigation of the Excel version of the MFRs, staff discovered Palm Valley calculated the non-U&U adjustment for wastewater using an incorrect set of depreciation expense accounts. Staff has recalculated the non-U&U adjustment using the correct depreciation expense accounts and recommends the non-U&U adjustment for wastewater should be decreased by $333. In total, staff recommends a non-U&U adjustment of $2,053 for the water system, and $23,410 for the wastewater system based on the corresponding non-U&U adjustments discussed above. This results in a total depreciation expense of $63,051 and $220,162 for the water and wastewater systems, respectively.

 

TOTI

In its filing, Palm Valley calculated TOTI balances of $25,600 for water and $49,915 for wastewater. Staff is recommending RAF adjustments to decrease water and wastewater TOTI by $3,959 and $9,989, respectively, based on the removal of the Utility’s requested increase as discussed above. Staff also recommends decreasing TOTI by $326 and $1,154 for water and wastewater, respectively, to remove property taxes associated with staff’s recommended non-U&U adjustments. As such, staff recommends TOTI balances of $21,315 ($25,600 - $3,959 - $326) and $38,772 ($49,915 - $9,989 - $1,154) for water and wastewater, respectively.

Summary

Based on the above, staff recommends a total decrease of $5,289 (-$1,004 - $4,285) to water Operating Expenses and $12,602 (-$1,791 + $333 - $11,143) to wastewater Operating Expenses. As such, staff recommends total Operating Expenses of $208,401 for water and $649,988 for wastewater.

 

Interim Revenue Requirement

In its filing, the Utility requested interim revenue requirements to generate annual revenue of $299,473 for water and $775,296 for wastewater. Based on the above adjustments, staff’s recommended interim rate of return resulted in a revenue requirement that exceeded what Palm Valley requested. In such circumstances, it has been Commission practice to limit the revenue requirement to the level requested by a Utility.[5] However, the Utility’s request is held artificially low because it did not reflect the correct ROE as established in the 2010 Rate Case Order. Staff  recommends using the minimum of the range of the ROE authorized in the Utility's last rate case,  pursuant to Section 367.082, F.S.

As such, staff recommends an interim revenue requirement of $308,303 for the water system, and $785,983 for the wastewater system. This represents interim increases in annual revenues of $96,815, or 45.78 percent, for water and $232,660, or 42.05 percent, for wastewater. The schedules for operating income are attached as Schedules 3-A, 3-B, and 3-C.


Issue 3: 

 What are the appropriate interim water and wastewater rates?

Recommendation: 

 The interim rate increase of 45.97 percent for water and 42.11 percent for wastewater should be applied as an across-the-board increase to the water and wastewater rates, respectively. The rates, as shown on Schedule Nos. 4-A and 4-B should be effective for service rendered on or after the stamped approval date on the tariff sheets pursuant to Rule 25-30-475(1), F.A.C. The Utility should file revised tariff sheets and a proposed customer notice to reflect the Commission-approved rates. In addition, the approved rates should not be implemented until the required security has been filed, staff has approved the proposed customer notice, and the notice has been received by the customers. The Utility should provide proof of the date notice was given within 10 days of the date of the notice. (Bethea)

Staff Analysis: 

 Staff recommends that interim service rates for Palm Valley be designed to allow the Utility the opportunity to generate annual operating revenues of $308,303 for water and $785,983 for wastewater. Before removal of miscellaneous revenues, this would result in an increase of $96,815 (or 45.78 percent) for water and $232,660 (or 42.05 percent) for wastewater. To determine the appropriate percentage increase to apply to the service rates, miscellaneous revenues should be removed from test year operating revenues. The calculation is as follows:

 

Table 3-1

Percentage Service Rate Increase

 

Water

Wastewater

1 Total Test Year Operating Revenues

$211,488

$553,323

2 Less: Miscellaneous Revenues

$875

$875

3 Test Year Revenues from Service Rates

$210,613

$552,448

4 Revenue Increase

$96,815

$232,660

5 Percentage Service Rate Increase (Line 4/ Line 3)

45.97%

42.11%

    Source: Staff’s Interim Recommended Revenue Requirement

 

The interim rate increase of 45.97 percent for water and 42.11 percent for wastewater should be applied as an across-the-board increase to the water and wastewater rates, respectively. The rates, as shown on Schedule Nos. 4-A and 4-B should be effective for service rendered on or after the stamped approval date on the tariff sheets pursuant to Rule 25-30-475(1), F.A.C. The Utility should file revised tariff sheets and a proposed customer notice to reflect the Commission-approved rates. In addition, the approved rates should not be implemented until the required security has been filed, staff has approved the proposed customer notice, and the notice has been received by the customers. The Utility should provide proof of the date notice was given within 10 days of the date of the notice.


Issue 4: 

 What is the appropriate security to guarantee the interim increase?

Recommendation: 

 The appropriate security to guarantee the funds collected subject to refund is a corporate undertaking by Hometown Communities Limited Partnership (Hometown Communities) on behalf of its subsidiary, Palm Valley. Hometown Communities should be required to provide a written guarantee that it will support a corporate undertaking on behalf of Palm Valley in the amount of $222,570. (Maxwell)

Staff Analysis: 

 Pursuant to Section 367.082, F.S., revenues collected under interim rates shall be placed under bond, escrow, letter of credit, or corporate undertaking subject to refund with interest at a rate ordered by the Commission. As recommended in Issue 1, the total interim increase is $329,475. In accordance with Rule 25-30.360, F.A.C., staff calculated the potential refund of revenues and interest collected under interim conditions to be $222,570. This amount is based on an estimated 8-month collection period of interim rates.

The criterion for a corporate undertaking includes sufficient liquidity, equity ownership, and profitability to guarantee any potential refund. Staff reviewed Palm Valley’s parent company, Hometown Communities’ 2023, 2024, and 2025 confidential financial statements filed with the Commission to determine if Palm Valley can support a corporate undertaking for the requested amount.[6] Staff’s analysis indicated that over the three-year period ending December 31, 2025, the Utility’s parent, Hometown Communities, has sufficient profitability, interest coverage, and equity ownership over the period. However, its liquidity is insufficient due to negative working capital but has an acceptable level of cash available which is sufficient to support a corporate undertaking in the amount of $222,570.

Based on the analysis of Hometown Communities’ financial position, staff recommends that Palm Valley can support a corporate undertaking in the amount of $222,570. Staff’s recommendation is contingent upon Hometown Communities providing a signed letter by a corporate officer or partner that it will support Palm Valley in its corporate undertaking endeavor. A parent company supporting a corporate undertaking on behalf of its subsidiary for interim purposes is consistent with Commission practice in prior rate cases.[7]

This brief financial analysis is only appropriate for determining if the Utility, through its parent, can support a corporate undertaking in the amount proposed and should not be considered a finding regarding staff’s position on other issues in this proceeding. In no instance should maintenance and administrative costs associated with any refund be borne by the customers. Such costs are the responsibility of, and should be borne by, the Utility.

Pursuant to Rule 25-30.360(6), F.A.C., the Utility should provide a report by the 20th day of each month indicating the monthly and total revenue collected subject to refund. Should a refund be required, the refund should be with interest and undertaken in accordance with Rule 25-30.360, F.A.C.


Issue 5: 

 Should this docket be closed?

Recommendation: 

 The docket should remain open pending the Commission’s final action on the Utility’s requested rate increase. (Rauch)

Staff Analysis: 

 The docket should remain open pending the Commission’s final action on the Utility’s requested rate increase.


 

 


 


 

 





 

 


 

 

 


 



[1] Order No. PSC-10-0606-PAA-WS, issued October 4, 2010, in Docket No. 20090447-WS, In re: Application for staff-assisted rate case in Seminole County by CWS Communities d/b/a Palm Valley Utilities.

[2] Order No. PSC-2010-0606-FOF-WS, issued October 4, 20130, in Docket No. 20090447-WS, In re: Application for staff-assisted rate case in Seminole County by CWS Communities d/b/a Palm Valley Utilities.

[3] Document No. 07832-2026.

[4] Order No. PSC-2010-0606-PAA-WS, issued October 4, 2010, in Docket No. 20090447-WS, In re: Application for staff-assisted rate case in Seminole County by CWS Communities d/b/a Palm Valley Utilities.

[5] Order Nos. PSC-13-0673-FOF-WS, issued December 19, 2013, in Docket No. 130212-WS, In re: Application for increase in water/wastewater rates in Polk County by Cypress Lakes Utilities, Inc.; PSC-10-0018-PCO-WS, issued January 6, 2010, in Docket No. 090402-WS, In re: Application for increase in water and wastewater rates in Seminole County by Sanlando Utilities Corporation; PSC-06-0675-PCO-SU, issued August 7, 2006, in Docket No. 060255-SU, In re: Application for increase in wastewater rates in Pinellas County by Tierra Verde Utilities, Inc.; PSC-05-0287-PAA-SU, issued March 17, 2005, in Docket No. 040972-SU, In re: Application for rate increase in Pinellas County by Ranch Mobile WWTP, Inc.; and PSC-95-0191-FOF-WS, issued February 9, 1995, in Docket No. 940917-WS, In re: Application for rate increase for increased water and wastewater rates in Seminole, Orange, and Pasco Counties by Utilities, Inc. of Florida.

[6] Document No. 07726-2026, filed on November 4, 2026.

[7] Order No. PSC-2023-0387-PCO-WS, issued December 27, 2023, in Docket No. 20230083-WS, In re: Application for increase in water and wastewater rates in Orange County by Pluris Wedgefield, LLC; Order No. PSC-2025-0361-PCO-WS, issued September 24, 2025, in Docket No. 20250052-WS, In re: Application for increase in water and wastewater rates in Brevard, Citrus, Duval, Highlands, Marion, and Volusia County by CSWR-Florida Utility Operating Company.